This coverage is made possible through a partnership between Grist and Verite News, a nonprofit news organization with a mission to produce in-depth journalism in underserved communities in the New Orleans area.
Arthur Matherne is accustomed to speeding his airboat across a southeastern stretch of the Louisiana coast where lakes and bayous have steadily widened over the decades. As the salty waters of the Gulf of Mexico have pushed inland, they have dissolved fragile marshes and swamps, transforming a once-dense mosaic of land and water into an increasingly open expanse.
But in one tucked-away patch of the Barataria Basin’s 1.6 million acres, the semi-retired tour guide eases off the throttle as he tries to remember his way through channels that have grown tighter by the year. Native grasses are aggressively overtaking the shallows, and low-slung oak branches are spreading overhead, dangling curtains of Spanish moss over narrow waterways he once barreled through without hesitation.
“All this, it’s filling in,” Matherne said after shutting off his airboat’s roaring propeller, looking out over the altered landscape. “Right here, it used to be three feet of water. Now it’s three inches.”
What Matherne is witnessing firsthand is a striking reversal of a destructive geographic pattern that has defined southern Louisiana for the past century. While much of the broader coastal zone has continued to recede at an average rate of about 11 square miles per year due to severe erosion, sea-level rise, and other forces compounded by climate change, the wetlands in this specific corner are actively gaining ground.
The primary driver of this unexpected renaissance sits just a few miles away. Near Luling in St. Charles Parish, the Davis Pond Freshwater Diversion has funneled Mississippi River water into the vast basin since the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers constructed it in 2002. The project’s original intent was straightforward: to combat the relentless creep of saltwater intrusion that was degrading local ecosystems.
However, once the project came online, something remarkable and unexpected happened. The diversion also carried the muddy river’s heavy load of sediment deep into the interior wetlands, elevating the underwater floor and helping to construct brand-new land where open water once prevailed.
“It’s had this unintended consequence of building land,” said Jacob Berkowitz, an Army Corps of Engineers wetland scientist. “This became one of the strategies that’s considered a key to addressing coastal land loss in Louisiana.”
The Rise and Fall of Mega-Diversions
Even as Davis Pond clearly demonstrates the tangible, land-building potential of river diversions, the state of Louisiana has abruptly abandoned its most ambitious, multi-billion-dollar attempt to scale up that exact approach. Last year, state officials canceled the massive Mid-Barataria Sediment Diversion—a $3 billion project directly inspired by the successes at Davis Pond. The venture had once been heralded by the state as the largest and boldest environmental restoration project in U.S. history.
Though construction crews broke ground on the monumental project in 2023, work ground to a halt shortly after Governor Jeff Landry, a Republican and one of the diversion’s most prominent and vocal critics, assumed office in 2024. Landry officially terminated the project, which would have been located roughly 20 miles south of New Orleans, in July 2025.

Landry repeatedly characterized the massive diversion as a costly, high-risk, and ultimately ineffective experiment. He argued that the influx of fresh water would devastate the region’s vital commercial fishing industry by flooding parts of Barataria Bay with too much fresh water and sediment, thereby pushing valuable shrimp populations offshore and burying delicate public and private oyster beds under feet of mud.
“This project is going to break our culture,” Landry told state lawmakers during legislative hearings in 2024. “It will destroy the shrimping industry—which is already struggling—and destroy the oyster beds.”
Following through on those concerns, the Landry administration also quietly canceled a vital companion project: the $1.8 billion Mid-Breton Sediment Diversion, which had been aimed at reviving dying wetlands situated southeast of New Orleans.
Despite the governor’s vocal opposition to these mega-projects, however, his administration is quietly planning and funding a series of smaller-scale diversions along the Mississippi River.
Officials with the Louisiana Coastal Protection and Restoration Authority, or CPRA, declined to discuss the state’s evolving diversion strategy directly. Yet a detailed Verite News review of the authority’s official budget documents reveals that the state plans to spend at least $340 million across five distinct projects over the next several years to divert Mississippi River water to restore and protect coastal wetlands.
That planned expenditure represents a significant financial increase over past state spending on diversions. According to the agency’s 2027 annual plan, the CPRA has completed just three diversion projects totaling $47 million since 2007.
Harnessing the Ancient Delta Cycle
While certain state political leaders may publicly disparage large-scale diversions, staff scientists at the CPRA remain steadfast in their belief that utilizing river water to rebuild land and restore collapsing wetlands is fundamentally sound science. At its core, a diversion is simply designed to mimic how the Mississippi River functioned naturally before a massive system of levees walled off its historic floodplain, preventing the river from regularly overflowing its banks or carving through them at natural breach points known as crevasses.
Brian Gossman, a CPRA coastal scientist, explained this underlying philosophy during a public lecture in March, emphasizing that engineers are merely working with geologic history rather than inventing a new paradigm.
“The natural process that we’re attempting to harness is the Delta cycle,” Gossman said. “It’s the same process that built all of coastal Louisiana over millennia. We’re just using it in a targeted way.”
Nearly all of the CPRA’s newly allocated diversion spending is slated to flow into a single major undertaking: the comprehensive restoration of the Maurepas Swamp, a sprawling wetland roughly the size of Chicago situated along the western edge of Lake Pontchartrain, about 25 miles from New Orleans.

The $334 million project, which officially broke ground in 2024, involves installing massive control gates within the Mississippi River levee near Garyville in St. John the Baptist Parish. Once operational, the system will channel up to 2,000 cubic feet per second of nutrient-rich river water directly into the Maurepas basin.
Despite its size, the swamp remains heavily degraded, having lost thousands of acres of historic cypress and tupelo forest over the decades. Levees constructed along the river in the early 1900s effectively cut the swamp off from its life-giving supply of fresh water and suspended sediment, leaving its remaining mature trees uniquely vulnerable to encroaching saltwater intrusion.
According to projections from the CPRA, the new diversion will simultaneously rebuild lost landmass and flush out stagnant, highly saline water, effectively rejuvenating approximately 45,000 acres of stressed forest. Construction on the initiative is currently scheduled for completion late next year.
At the same time, the state has not entirely abandoned the concept of diverting sediment into the critically vulnerable Barataria Basin. Following the cancellation of the much larger Mid-Barataria project, the agency dusted off an earlier, significantly scaled-down alternative: the Medium Diversion at Myrtle Grove. Originally proposed more than 25 years ago, this project would channel up to 15,000 cubic feet of river water per second into the basin—representing roughly one-third of the operational capacity planned for the scrapped Mid-Barataria diversion. To accelerate the creation of stable marshland, the authority also intends to dredge sediment directly from the bed of the Mississippi River and pump it mechanically into the surrounding basin.
The exact timeline and final budget for the Myrtle Grove project remain somewhat uncertain. Current CPRA budget documents indicate that approximately $1.7 million could be spent on preliminary planning and engineering between 2027 and 2029, but the total completion cost is expected to run much higher. When it was last evaluated in 2012, the project carried an estimated price tag of $278 million, which translates to roughly $480 million in today’s dollars.
Furthermore, CPRA’s updated spending plans include fresh investments to optimize the existing Davis Pond diversion. The agency has proposed dedicating $3 million, split with the Army Corps of Engineers, to rigorously study how the facility can be operated differently to maximize land-building capabilities.
Prior research led by Tulane University in 2019 suggested that safely boosting the diversion’s average operational flow from its baseline of 1,000 cubic feet per second up to a range between 4,000 and 7,000 cubic feet per second could deliver substantially more sediment to starving interior wetlands. However, researchers cautioned that if water flows are allowed to run too high, incoming sediment could be swept right through the marsh and flushed out into open water.
Local officials in St. Charles Parish, which hosts the Davis Pond facility, strongly support finding practical ways to increase the diversion’s output. In its 2025 local habitat restoration plan, the parish formally endorsed the proposed CPRA study, pointing directly to persistent public criticism that the state’s historical management of the diversion has been far too conservative to yield maximum environmental benefits.
The Ongoing Scientific Debate Over Diversion Impacts
Out on the water, watching the silty flows of Davis Pond creep past the hull of his airboat, Matherne expressed no doubt that the diversion needs to release significantly more water and sediment to keep pace with regional land loss.
“Right now, it’s like pissing in an Olympic-size swimming pool,” Matherne said. “We need more flow.”

Proponents point out that the Army Corps originally built the diversion to safeguard local oyster populations that had suffered as surrounding coastal marshes deteriorated and salinity levels climbed. While commercial oyster abundance in the immediate area has fluctuated notably since the project’s inception, recent state monitoring data show that populations on public seed grounds managed to climb above their 10-year averages in 2024, according to Danielle Richardi, a CPRA coastal scientist. Furthermore, commercial shrimp catches recorded south of the diversion hit a nearly four-decade high that same year.
For his part, Matherne noted that he has observed a dramatic, visible increase in local wildlife populations throughout the area. Alligators have become noticeably more plentiful, he said, pointing out more than a dozen of the apex predators resting along the banks as his boat navigated the intricate maze of flooded waterways.
“All the alligators you see—that’s a fraction of what’s out there,” Matherne said. “Come back at night, and you’ll see their eyes shining all over.”
Despite these encouraging localized signs, scientific consensus on the broader, long-term efficacy of river diversions remains deeply divided. While numerous studies have documented how accumulated river sediment has successfully built new land patches near these structures, independent researchers have reached starkly conflicting conclusions regarding the net impact on overall wetland acreage over time.
In 2019, Eugene Turner, a coastal sciences professor at Louisiana State University, challenged conventional thinking surrounding river diversions by publishing a controversial study that linked the operation of Davis Pond to an apparent acceleration in regional wetland loss. Turner discovered that the annual rate of wetland deterioration near Davis Pond nearly tripled after the diversion began active operations, jumping from 0.36 percent to more than 1 percent per year. This increase outpaced the rate of land loss observed in nearby control wetlands that remained unaffected by the diversion.
According to Turner, a major part of the problem lies in the chemical composition of the river water itself. While diversions are engineered to restore the Mississippi’s historical connections to its surrounding delta, the modern river is fundamentally different than it was a century ago. Today, it carries exceptionally high concentrations of nitrogen and phosphorus, largely driven by agricultural fertilizer and manure runoff from upstream farms, alongside treated wastewater discharged by major metropolitan areas.
Turner argues that these massive loads of excess nutrients stimulate unnaturally rapid plant growth, producing marsh vegetation that is structurally weak and shallow-rooted.
“If your garden is fertilized too much, it puts all its growth aboveground,” Turner explained. “It falls over because its roots never had to work hard.”
In Turner’s view, lower ambient nutrient levels encourage native marsh plants to develop much more robust, extensive root systems, making the resulting wetlands far more resilient against severe wind and wave erosion. He famously likens some of the apparent, short-term land gains produced by diversions to a “green toupee”—superficially giving the visual impression that marshes are filling in, while remaining vulnerable to being easily stripped away by severe storms or strong tidal currents.
Conversely, two of Turner’s academic colleagues at LSU strongly disputed those findings in a subsequent 2023 study. John White and John Day, both prominent coastal sciences professors, concluded that the first two decades of Davis Pond operations had actually generated a net gain of 1.3 square miles of stable land. Their published research asserted that Turner had reached an erroneous conclusion by relying on satellite data that were explicitly labeled as inappropriate for fine-scale coastal monitoring.

The researchers argued that Turner’s remote-sensing data lacked the precise resolution needed to accurately distinguish between small, isolated patches of emergent wetland vegetation and shallow open water, creating the false statistical appearance of land disappearing when it was actually expanding.
While Turner firmly stands by his original findings, arguing that they provide an essential cautionary perspective on the risks poorly managed diversions pose to fragile ecosystems, the ongoing debate heavily influenced public discourse surrounding larger state projects.
Opponents of the now-canceled Mid-Barataria diversion frequently cited Turner’s research during bruising public hearings. Those concerns, combined with official CPRA projections indicating the massive project could bury public oyster beds under thick sediment layers and drive commercial shrimp stocks further out to sea, ultimately drained the project of its remaining political and financial backing.
“Considering the uncertainties and questionable environmental outcomes recognized by various agencies … it was necessary to abandon the current project,” CPRA Chairman Gordon Dove wrote in a guest column published in The Times-Picayune.
Although the state agency has yet to publish a comprehensive, overarching framework detailing its pivot in coastal restoration strategy, prioritizing smaller, more financially manageable, and geographically targeted projects is clearly the new path forward.
Turner cautiously welcomes this shift toward smaller operations, though he maintains that any future diversions should be carefully managed to run at lower, more controlled flow rates. Doing so, he argues, would prevent the destruction of vegetation that he believes has been weakened by chronic nutrient loading, while advising planners to focus future construction efforts in areas characterized by naturally sandy soils rather than the ultra-soft, unstable mud found across many coastal marshes.
“It’s not that they won’t work,” Turner said. “These diversions give you lessons. We should learn from them.”