Nearly 7 out of 10 early-career teachers leave or consider leaving the profession within their first five years, according to data from the Center for American Progress. That sobering statistic carries a heavy weight for educators who are just starting out in the field. For a science teacher who only began leading a classroom in 2025, navigating the day-to-day realities of lesson planning, classroom management, and student motivation can quickly become an overwhelming trial by fire.
To help anchor professional development and build foundational skills, many new educators turn to specialized training programs. One such initiative is the Stanford Teacher Education Program (STEP). Having recently graduated from the program, a newly minted science teacher sought out further professional development by signing up for an additional round of workshops. To their initial surprise, however, the curriculum did not focus strictly on traditional pedagogy, lesson design, or subject-matter delivery. Instead, the core activities centered on an unexpected medium: improvisational theater.
Improv, or improvisational theater, is traditionally recognized as an artistic performance form where actors spontaneously invent dialogue, settings, and complex plotlines on the spot for an audience. While improv certainly has an established home on the stage and in comedy clubs, drawing a direct line from theatrical games to a modern science classroom initially felt counterintuitive and out of place.
Stepping into the workshop environment required vulnerability. Participants found themselves making up stories and acting out scenes with fellow teachers as though they had known each other for decades. Yet, participating felt inherently risky, exposing individuals to the critical judgment of peers. Observing their own mistakes happen in real time in front of colleagues made hesitation creep in, dampening the urge to fully engage. Through these exercises, however, a profound realization emerged about the emotional and psychological stakes of learning. The activities highlighted the deep level of vulnerability that comes with acquiring new knowledge, demonstrating firsthand how self-doubt and the fear of embarrassment can severely stunt student engagement.
This theatrical approach inspired a reevaluation of how learning is facilitated in subjects like science, which many students historically find difficult, often causing them to shut down entirely. Rather than relying on traditional methods like cold-calling for student responses or immediately spotlighting only the "right" answer, educators could leverage elements of improv to introduce the foundational importance of risk-taking, ultimately encouraging students to embrace risks of their own.
A New Frame for Teaching
While designing rigorous learning experiences and mastering academic content often appear to be the absolute heart of education, they do not encompass everything a teacher must balance to cultivate a successful, thriving classroom. Other critical factors, including student engagement, exert just as much of an impact on academic outcomes. According to a Yale University study published in the Journal of Educational Psychology, student engagement serves as the vital driving force behind classroom environments that are truly conducive to deep learning and long-term academic achievement.
Nevertheless, high levels of engagement are rarely guaranteed the moment students walk through the door. While certain students feel completely comfortable raising their hands, offering spontaneous answers, or eagerly collaborating with classmates, others find these forms of public participation deeply unnerving and stressful.
"Learning itself is risky," says Marti Lane, a doctoral student in mathematics education who co-led the improv activities at STEP. "It is vulnerable, it is scary, it is uncertain."
Many students go to great lengths to avoid "looking dumb" by sharing an incorrect answer or misunderstanding a complex concept. This persistent shroud of uncertainty can stall student engagement and, ultimately, halt the learning process within the classroom. Improv offers a simple yet effective mechanism for early-career teachers to become significantly more comfortable with risk-taking themselves, enabling them to help students try out new ideas without the crippling pressure of immediate academic performance.
What Counts as Improv?
Human beings are constantly navigating complex social environments and adapting their behavior to project a "front-stage" self that is perceived as socially acceptable, a dynamic famously noted by Canadian-American sociologist Erving Goffman in 1959. Teachers engage in this behavioral balancing act continuously, carefully selecting what they wear, modulating how they speak to families, and making tactical instructional decisions in real time.

However, it is not only teachers who constantly improvise—students do it as well. In student-centered activities, whether learners are sharing rough ideas with a peer, contributing to a culminating project, or simply helping a neighbor, an underlying drive to appear competent in front of others heavily influences their actions. While this social drive may never entirely disappear, improv-inspired activities can serve as an effective pathway to make students more open and resilient to making mistakes.
Putting theory into practice, one science educator recently introduced an improv-inspired exercise in their own classroom. Students were instructed to find a peer wearing the same style of shoes and work together to invent their own unique handshakes. The activity was designed as a low-stakes way for students to practice reaching out to classmates they might not otherwise know, experimenting with what works socially, and risking rejection if someone chose not to accept their ideas.
In the past, traditional lessons often drove disengaged students to withdraw by putting their heads down or asking to use the restroom excessively. During this specific exercise, however, the classroom dynamic shifted visibly. Students emerged from their shells smiling, socializing, and eagerly bouncing ideas off each other as they crafted personalized handshakes. The activity successfully lowered the barrier for participation, helping students collaborate with one another much more readily during the science lesson that immediately followed.
Executing a brand-new type of activity naturally brought feelings of nervousness. Embracing vulnerability with students without knowing how they would react is never easy. Yet, it was precisely through this experiment that the teacher discovered a genuine, practical room for improv within science education. Improv helped instructors step back into the shoes of the student, restoring an appreciation for the vulnerability of taking risks. Memories of dreading the moment of not having an answer for a class, watching a lesson plan go south, or fumbling a laboratory demonstration in front of everyone suddenly resurfaced. Ultimately, the experience proved that professional growth as an early-career teacher is impossible without taking risks. It highlighted that centering mistakes, silliness, and joy in a science classroom is not only acceptable but necessary to humanize teaching and reach a broader range of students.
Driven by these promising results, the teacher took yet another risk by sharing the methodology with older, more experienced colleagues. To their surprise, veteran educators were deeply intrigued by what improv had to offer their own students. After hearing about how handshake creation fostered student engagement, a senior colleague requested the specific protocols and guidance on what to anticipate if implemented in future classes.
Connecting Improv to Young Teachers
Lisa Rowland, a lecturer in Stanford University’s Department of Theater and Performance Studies and a STEP instructor, believes that improv encourages early-career teachers to "transform their relationship to failure." Through these theatrical exercises, young teachers who struggle to connect with their students begin to realize that the fundamental educational challenge is not a matter of avoiding student failure, but rather understanding and shaping how students respond when failure occurs.
Science is already recognized as an intimidating subject for many students, and educators know firsthand how discouraging early mistakes can be. Yet, those same mistakes remain essential to the cognitive learning process, frequently paving the way for the most enduring and transformative educational breakthroughs.
Engaging with improv prompts critical self-reflection among educators: Are classrooms truly fostering environments where mistakes are allowed and celebrated rather than shamed and discouraged? How does an instructor react when an answer deviates from the correct one? What do subtle body language cues convey when an incorrect response is given? Whose contributions are elevated, and whose are quietly dismissed, and why?
Ultimately, the emphasis on risk-taking embedded within improv provides a crucial turning point for evaluating overall classroom environments. It illuminates the massive psychological barriers that many students face when trying to participate, collaborate, or engage with difficult material, inspiring a more empathetic approach to tackling classroom disengagement. By embracing improv, early-career teachers can better understand how to cultivate healthy risk-taking, building learning environments that are safe, engaging, and genuinely open to mistakes for students and educators alike.