Plastic pollution blights the streets, beaches, parks, and lawns of Baltimore and communities across the United States. A significant amount of that ubiquitous litter bears the circular red-and-blue Pepsi logo or the flowing white script of Coca-Cola’s iconic branding.
Yet, legally speaking, none of that accumulated rubbish is Pepsi’s fault. Nor is it Coke’s.
That is precisely what a Baltimore city circuit court judge ruled this summer following a hard-fought legal battle in which the city and county of Baltimore sought substantial financial damages from PepsiCo, Coca-Cola, and other corporate entities to fund widespread cleanups of plastic pollution. Companies “conducting lawful activities,” wrote Judge Audrey J.S. Carrión, referring to the commercial sale of single-use plastics, “should not be held liable under public nuisance claims because others are misusing the products in an unlawful manner.”
In other words, according to this judicial perspective, plastic pollution is fundamentally a problem of consumer behavior, not corporate irresponsibility. As far as state public nuisance laws are concerned, a manufacturer’s legal liability ends cleanly at the point of sale.
Similar judicial reasoning has recently scuttled a public nuisance lawsuit filed by the state of New York against PepsiCo and Frito-Lay, and the same fundamental debate has emerged in similar litigation stretching from Missouri to California. As environmental advocates, local governments, and state officials continue to develop and test this legal theory, those significant setbacks raise a fundamental question: When does a company’s responsibility for its products truly end? And can public nuisance laws ever succeed in making major corporate polluters pay for the widespread environmental damage caused by their goods?
The legal notion of a public nuisance dates back centuries to 13th-century English common law and traditionally applied to violations of rights shared broadly by the general public, such as free and safe access to clean air and public waterways. However, since the 1970s, plaintiffs have increasingly attempted to apply that legal doctrine to manufacturers whose products allegedly jeopardize public health, safety, and access to a clean environment.
These ambitious lawsuits, however, have a mixed record of success, according to Timothy Lytton, a professor at the Georgia State University College of Law. High-profile cases targeting opioid manufacturers, e-cigarette companies, and even the landmark historical litigation against Big Tobacco have sometimes achieved notable results—but mostly by securing favorable financial settlements out of court, rather than because judges ultimately ruled in favor of the sweeping public-nuisance arguments presented by plaintiffs.
Cases that have actually proceeded to substantive hearings, meanwhile, have continually struggled to convince skeptical judges of “causation,” or the core legal idea that corporate defendants are substantially responsible for violating a public right. Judges have shown themselves consistently wary of extending corporate liability past the lawful, authorized sale of commercial products, particularly when those products are not ultimately used as intended by the manufacturer. If a licensed doctor or a patient diverts prescription opioids to the illicit black market, for example, courts have questioned whether the manufacturing pharmaceutical companies should be held legally responsible for the resulting societal harm.

This is essentially the exact conclusion Judge Carrión reached in the Baltimore case. It also directly echoes sharp questioning from Justice Stephen Lindley last month as he heard oral arguments in the appeal of New York’s high-profile Pepsi lawsuit.
“If [Pepsi] has to pay for the cleanup when somebody else is littering, … it’s not going to be sustainable,” he told the plaintiff’s lawyers during the court session. He appeared visibly sympathetic to arguments raised by PepsiCo attorney Andrew Tulumello, who contended that the state faced a “honking causation problem.” Pepsi, Tulumello argued before the court, is simply “not encouraging people to throw stuff in the litter.”
According to Albert Lin, co-director of the California Environmental Law and Policy Center at the University of California, Davis, there are three basic, necessary elements required to successfully sustain a public-nuisance lawsuit. The first is demonstrating a “substantial interference with a public right.” The second essential element is causation—meaning a direct legal link connecting a defendant’s actions to that interference. The third element, he noted, involves proving negligence, intent, or other “tortious conduct” inherent in the defendant’s commercial activities.
Environmental groups and local governments are actively trying to bypass the traditional point-of-sale argument by closely linking causation and tortious conduct. Plastics companies, they argue in their complaints, are directly responsible for the accelerating pollution crisis and knew full well that their standard business actions would severely harm public rights. Consequently, courts will inevitably pay close attention to the legal concept of “foreseeability”—specifically, whether it was entirely foreseeable to manufacturers that single-use plastic packaging would routinely end up as environmental litter, Lin explained. As Lytton put it, manufacturers allegedly acted “in a way that foreseeably increases the risk of misuse.” Notably, the word “foreseeable” appears no fewer than 22 times in Baltimore’s comprehensive legal complaint.
Plaintiffs point to a growing body of documentary evidence to support their argument that widespread plastic pollution was not only foreseeable but anticipated. At least some major manufacturers have known for decades that the mass production of single-use plastics would inevitably contribute to severe environmental contamination, and that municipal recycling systems would be fundamentally incapable of managing the massive volume of waste. The lawsuits also frequently cite microplastics contamination as a core component of the alleged nuisance. An investigative report published by the Los Angeles Times revealed that industry scientists have understood since at least the 1970s that microplastics could lodge directly in human bodies.
That troubling historical record deeply informs the overarching framing offered by Scott Hochberg, general counsel and litigation director for the nonprofit Earth Island Institute.
“Companies induced consumers to purchase these products while knowing the likelihood that they would end up as trash,” he said. “And that’s exactly what happened.”
Whether this strategic legal framing ultimately succeeds may depend heavily on the specific jurisdiction in which the lawsuit is filed. In addition to the strict causation requirements required for public-nuisance lawsuits, Lin noted that some states maintain a much higher legal standard for demonstrating that defendants retained “control” over their commercial products at the exact moment the public nuisance occurred. New York and Maryland are two such states with stringent standards. California, on the other hand, is not, and state and federal courts there have so far proven notably more receptive to plastics-related public nuisance suits.

Judge Richard Seeborg of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California, who is currently overseeing two distinct lawsuits targeting Exxon Mobil Corp., previously allowed one major case brought by the Sierra Club to proceed to trial, though he has not yet ruled on a separate action brought by the state’s attorney general.
Yet even in progressive jurisdictions like California, surviving an early judicial challenge is no absolute guarantee of ultimate success. A federal judge in California previously allowed the Earth Island Institute’s public-nuisance claim—which rested in part on allegations of misleading recycling labels—to move forward against 10 major food and beverage companies. However, the case was ultimately rejected in a summary judgment ruling. Earth Island officials have indicated they plan to appeal the decision.
Representatives for Pepsi, Coca-Cola, and Exxon Mobil did not respond to multiple requests for comment regarding the ongoing litigation.
Lin emphasized that it is still “early days” for this emerging legal theory, and recent judicial rejections do not necessarily signal a permanently losing strategy for environmental advocates. He noted, however, that courts have shown significant institutional skepticism toward public nuisance claims in ongoing climate change litigation, and a major case currently being heard by the U.S. Supreme Court could soon make it significantly more difficult for cities and states to bring such sweeping claims in the future.
Lin added that in climate-related lawsuits, plaintiffs have increasingly leaned more heavily on allegations of deceptive corporate conduct, successfully invoking consumer protection and false advertising statutes that can often be substantially easier to substantiate in court than broad claims based on public nuisance. Plastics plaintiffs could potentially pursue a similar strategic path, he suggested, which might result in winning financial damages—though it would likely not secure judicial orders requiring companies to physically clean up the existing pollution their products have created.
At the same time, public nuisance laws could soon face entirely new legislative constraints at the state level. Montana enacted a first-of-its-kind law preempting state and local public-nuisance lawsuits based on “lawful activities,” while officials in Kansas and Utah have since enacted their own similar legislative restrictions. All three states’ new laws are closely connected to model legislation drafted by the American Legislative Exchange Council, a conservative policy organization that brings together state lawmakers and private-sector members to develop standardized model policies.
Whatever their ultimate outcome inside the courtroom, Lytton observed that these high-profile plastics lawsuits can still effectively “win” in other important ways—by unearthing previously hidden corporate documents during discovery, for instance, and by thrusting the global plastics crisis much higher onto the mainstream public-policy agenda. They also provide a vital platform for plaintiffs to forcefully refute the plastics industry’s long-standing consumer-responsibility narrative.
“When you file a lawsuit, what you’re doing is you’re telling a story—often about some sort of structural or corporate wrongdoing,” Lytton said. “When you talk about tobacco, it’s not just about smokers. Or opioids, it’s not just about users. It’s about the companies and their design and marketing decisions. And so the framing that goes on in these [lawsuits] is moving the discussion of plastics away from ‘litterbugs’ and toward corporate responsibility.”