For several years, federal pandemic relief funds helped school districts across the United States expand "high-impact" or "high-dosage" tutoring programs that measurably improved student learning and helped counter widespread academic disruption. Now that the primary source of that financial backing has officially expired, education leaders nationwide are scrambling to keep those successful programs afloat, navigating a difficult landscape of shrinking budgets, structural redesigns, and the challenge of preserving academic gains.
Between March 2020 and March 2021, the U.S. Congress allocated nearly $190.5 billion to public education through the Elementary and Secondary School Emergency Relief (ESSER) fund. Representing the largest one-time federal investment in K-12 education in American history, ESSER provided the critical capital school systems needed to hire personnel, design interventions, and support students grappling with the academic and social fallout of the COVID-19 pandemic. Although that historic funding ended in phases between 2022 and 2024—with some districts receiving federal liquidation extensions to stretch their dollars further—the abrupt financial cliff has forced a hard reckoning for local school administrators.
In response to the funding expiration, some school districts have been forced to pause or significantly scale back their tutoring initiatives. Others, however, are working aggressively to save these programs by weaving them directly into their core academic systems, master schedules, and operating budgets. A 2026 analysis of 35 districts conducted by the National Student Support Accelerator (NSSA) revealed a split landscape: eight districts had significantly reduced their tutoring operations, and another eight had experienced a distinct pause or disruption following the end of ESSER. Yet, 19 districts—representing more than half of the institutions studied—successfully preserved or even expanded their tutoring programs despite the loss of emergency federal dollars.
Extensive educational research shows that high-impact or high-dosage tutoring has stood out as the single most powerful intervention deployed to make up for pandemic-related learning loss. Typically occurring at least three times a week, these programs provide targeted, individualized, or small-group instruction that coordinates closely with regular classroom work. According to the NSSA, programs featuring frequent sessions over a minimum of 10 weeks, delivered in small groups or one-on-one formats using data-driven instruction, can generate anywhere from three to 15 months of additional academic learning.
Despite these proven benefits, the financial reality remains a formidable barrier. Research from the Annenberg Institute at Brown University estimates that high-impact tutoring costs between $1,200 and $2,500 per student annually. Without the cushion of ESSER funds, absorbing these recurring expenses has proven exceptionally difficult for many local education agencies.
For schools that heavily invested in these initiatives and are determined to retain their long-term advantages, the central challenge is transforming tutoring from a temporary fix into a permanent, standard fixture of the school day. Devon Wible, vice president of teaching and learning at Catapult Learning, a provider of school tutoring programs, notes that education leaders in several states are increasingly viewing tutoring not as an optional add-on, but as a foundational layer of daily academic support.
"A few years ago, when ESSER funds were here, the conversation was, ‘Let’s see if it works,’" Wible observes. "Now it’s, ‘How do we sustain this?’"
Building Tutoring Into Existing Systems
One of the primary ways school districts are trying to ensure tutoring survives is by embedding it directly into the regular school day and aligning it with existing academic-support systems. While this integration does not completely eliminate the financial cost of providing instruction, it is considerably less expensive than establishing a separate, standalone extracurricular program that requires entirely independent staffing and facilities.
Wible explains that some districts have creatively modified their daily schedules by adding dedicated intervention periods or "WIN" (What I Need) blocks. These designated windows give students time to receive extra academic support without pulling them away from core classroom instruction. This strategic scheduling also encourages much tighter collaboration among classroom teachers, specialized tutors, and intervention staff, who can regularly share student data and work collaboratively toward common academic goals.
The tutoring itself is deliberately designed to align with ongoing classroom instruction. For instance, a student struggling with grade-level reading might receive targeted coaching on foundational phonics and decoding skills while continuing to engage with age-appropriate texts alongside their peers during standard class time. Schools rely on continuous, ongoing student data to identify specific academic needs, adjust instructional approaches, and determine precisely when a student has mastered a concept and is ready to exit the support program.
"Ultimately, our shared goal is that students experience classroom instruction, intervention and tutoring as one coherent learning experience," Wible says.
Wible has witnessed the tangible impact of this cohesive approach firsthand. A Catapult analysis of roughly 700 students spanning kindergarten through third grade across 12 Massachusetts school districts found that participants made substantial literacy gains after receiving high-impact tutoring, with some students achieving up to five additional months of reading progress. In one specific Massachusetts district, the results were particularly striking: after just 12 weeks of targeted tutoring, the proportion of kindergarten and first-grade students performing at or above grade level jumped dramatically from 11% to 55%, according to Wible.
Protecting What Works
While some districts find innovative paths forward, education policy experts warn that financial pressures could silently undermine the quality of academic interventions. David Blazar, an associate professor of education policy at the University of Maryland, suggests that the deeper concern may not be whether tutoring disappears entirely, but what happens to program quality when cash-strapped schools are forced to cut corners.
Blazar recently co-authored a University of Maryland study examining tutoring programs across all 24 of Maryland’s school districts to analyze how local systems are designing and scaling their operations. The analysis found that 18 districts offered tutoring featuring key elements associated with stronger implementation, such as small-group instruction, frequent weekly sessions, and delivery during regular school hours. Although the research focused specifically on Maryland, it offers broader insight into the dilemmas facing districts nationwide as they attempt to sustain academic support post-ESSER.
Blazar anticipates that as money grows tight, districts may consider increasing group sizes, reducing how often sessions occur, or turning to lower-cost, less rigorous providers rather than completely eliminating tutoring from their budgets.
"The more likely change is quieter and, in some ways, more consequential: erosion of the design features that make tutoring work," Blazar says. "When you have to find savings, dosage—and other components of quality, including how many students work with the same tutor simultaneously—are very likely to change."
However, Blazar’s analysis of implementation plans under the Blueprint for Maryland’s Future from 2024 to 2027 found that Maryland districts actively planned to restructure their schedules to keep tutoring alive. Because tutoring serves as a core mandate of the state’s landmark education reform policy, he expects local districts in Maryland to maintain their institutional commitment to the strategy.
"I think they will continue because it is a core part of the Blueprint, and there is growing consensus that tutoring is a critical resource for improving student outcomes, so it is money well spent," Blazar notes.
For school systems everywhere trying to stretch limited local and state dollars, the ultimate hurdle lies in figuring out where to trim administrative or operational costs without weakening the specific core design features that make high-impact tutoring effective in the first place.
One District’s Approach
West Feliciana Parish Schools in Louisiana provides a clear illustration of how a local district can successfully secure alternative funding sources to permanently integrate tutoring into the school day. Although the district had maintained baseline intervention and tutoring practices prior to 2024, it dramatically expanded and formalized its school-day high-dosage tutoring program during the 2024-25 academic year, aided by state funding made available through the Louisiana Department of Education’s Accelerate: High-Dosage Tutoring initiative.
To accommodate the program, West Feliciana created a schoolwide master schedule featuring a consistent 30- to 50-minute block each day when standard core instruction pauses. During this designated time, students are divided into targeted, skill-based groups and report either to their regular classroom teacher or a specialized interventionist for high-dosage tutoring, according to Jodi Lemoine, director of accountability at West Feliciana Parish Schools. Meanwhile, students who are not receiving tutoring during that block remain in the classroom to work independently on educational software or read library books, while fourth and fifth graders participate in online tutoring sessions managed through external providers.
This structural approach significantly expanded the reach of the district’s overall intervention efforts. Before the statewide initiative was implemented, the local reading intervention program served roughly 96 students per week. Lemoine reports that after one year of the new schedule, that figure surged to more than 430 students.
"From the get-go, our philosophy was: This is gonna require good teaching, not just programs," Lemoine says.
The district carefully monitors student progress every two to three weeks, making instructional adjustments as necessary based on data. Assessment data tracked between the fall and spring semesters of the 2025-26 school year demonstrated notable performance increases across participating cohorts.
The Louisiana Department of Education formally recognized the district as a Model of Excellence for its innovative approach to high-dosage tutoring. By December 2024, more than 45% of all kindergarten through fifth-grade students in the district were receiving tutoring—more than double the proportion served previously. Furthermore, about 60% of participating students successfully reached their targeted literacy skill benchmarks during the very first progress-monitoring checkpoint.
"We have figured out a way to use the resources we have smarter," Lemoine says. "Our high-dose tutoring program is truly an example of that: Work smarter, not harder."
Although the district currently relies on a careful combination of state and local funding streams to keep the program operating, school leadership remains firmly committed to its long-term survival. Superintendent Hollis Milton emphasizes that West Feliciana’s success proves academic interventions do not simply have to vanish the moment a temporary federal relief grant expires.
"If something’s working, you find the will, and then you’re gonna find the way," Milton says.