While depreciation remains an inevitable financial hurdle for anyone purchasing a new automobile, market data consistently points to a single brand that defies the traditional curve more effectively than any other: Toyota. According to comprehensive data compiled by automotive research firms CarEdge and iSeeCars, Toyota vehicles retain an impressive average of 64.9% of their original value after five years of ownership. This performance places the Japanese automaker comfortably at the top of the industry, ahead of competitors like Subaru, which holds the second position with an average five-year residual value of 61.2%.

To put Toyota’s market resilience into perspective, consider the broader automotive landscape. The average new vehicle typically sheds roughly 30% of its manufacturer’s suggested retail price within the first two years alone. By contrast, it takes a typical Toyota almost half a decade to experience a comparable percentage drop in value. Of course, that figure represents a broad average across the brand’s entire portfolio, with several specific nameplates boasting even more remarkable residual strengths.

Industry analysts look at long-term valuation track records by analyzing comprehensive market data, factoring in factory destination charges for original MSRPs while evaluating active secondary market listings from platforms like Autotrader. These used-vehicle valuations typically assume near-average mileage for a five-year-old vehicle—hovering around 68,000 miles—along with a clean vehicle history devoid of accidents or branded titles. A closer examination of Toyota’s standout models reveals how specific vehicles in the lineup perform when measured against both industry forecasts and real-world transaction prices.

Toyota Tacoma: 79.5%

Among vehicle owners and automotive enthusiasts, debates frequently arise regarding which generation represents the absolute pinnacle of the Toyota Tacoma. However, when examining financial metrics, there is virtually no debate: a five-year-old Tacoma stands undisputed as the residual-value champion among similarly aged Toyotas.

CarEdge data indicates that a Tacoma retains approximately 79% of its original value after five years, while iSeeCars offers a slightly more optimistic projection at 80.1%, resulting in a combined retained-value average of 79.5%. Expressed another way, the truck sheds a mere 4% of its value annually. Furthermore, iSeeCars lists the Tacoma among the elite tier of all vehicles nationwide for low depreciation, trailing only high-end sports cars like the Porsche Cayman, Porsche 911, and Chevrolet Corvette.

Real-world marketplace listings on Autotrader reinforce these extraordinary figures. A 2021 Tacoma configured in the SR5 trim with rear-wheel drive and a double cab commands an average price of roughly $29,500. Given that the original MSRP for this specific configuration was $33,405 including destination charges, the actual five-year depreciation sits at a modest 11.7%. This yields an actual residual value of 88.3%, outperforming the combined baseline estimates provided by major automotive tracking firms.

Toyota GR Supra: 77.2%

Although automotive enthusiasts continue to discuss the eventual departure of the GR Supra from the Toyota lineup following the 2026 model year, this sports car—developed in partnership with BMW—remains exceptionally robust on the used car market. CarEdge metrics point to a five-year residual value of 78.4%, while iSeeCars estimates a close 76%, bringing their combined average to 77.2%.

The GR Supra was originally introduced for the 2020 model year, with the subsequent 2021 edition expanding the lineup to include a lower-priced four-cylinder variant alongside a more potent inline-six model that received a notable 47-horsepower performance boost. Even though the four-cylinder variant launched with a more accessible base price of $43,985, secondary market pricing for a 2021 model typically hovers near $37,000. This places its retained value at an impressive 84.1%, surpassing standard depreciation forecasts.

For buyers leaning toward the higher-performance powertrain, the mid-grade 3.0 Premium trim—which originally carried an MSRP of $55,485—maintains an average listing price of approximately $47,000 on Autotrader. Given limited market inventory, this pricing points to an exceptionally strong resale retention rate of 84.7%.

Toyota Tundra: 77.2%

Toyota’s full-size entry in the highly competitive pickup truck segment, the Tundra, also secures a top-tier position for minimizing depreciation. However, five-year resale projections reveal a slight divergence between tracking sources, with CarEdge estimating 75.5% and iSeeCars projecting 78.8%. This gap of 3.3 percentage points can translate into a variance of over $1,200 for prospective buyers shopping the secondary market.

The 2021 model year represents the final iteration of the Tundra’s second generation, prior to the rollout of an entirely redesigned third generation. Looking at active marketplace data, the lower-tier SR5 trim equipped with the CrewMax configuration and rear-wheel drive originally retailed for $39,565 in 2021. Today, similarly equipped second-hand examples average about $36,000, translating to a striking 91% resale value—roughly 15.5 percentage points higher than CarEdge’s baseline projection. Moving up to the Limited grade, which originally started at $45,850 for a rear-wheel-drive CrewMax configuration, used models command approximately $41,000, retaining an estimated 89.4% of their original value.

Toyota Corolla Hatchback: 76.4%

While many domestic automotive manufacturers steadily scaled back production of compact cars, Toyota doubled down by introducing a hatchback variant to the modern Corolla family for the 2019 model year. This five-door configuration appears to have rewarded owners with particularly strong residual values compared to its traditional four-door sibling, though both body styles perform remarkably well.

CarEdge reports that a five-year-old Corolla Hatchback preserves 78.2% of its original MSRP, while iSeeCars places the figure at 74.5%, yielding a combined average of 76.4%. When specified with a continuously variable transmission, a 2021 Corolla Hatchback carried a base MSRP of $22,560. Available inventory on the secondary market frequently lists for around $20,000, pushing the actual five-year value retention even higher to 88.7%.

Historically, the Corolla Hatchback was also offered with a six-speed manual transmission—a configuration Toyota retired from the lineup after the 2023 model year. In 2021, the base manual-equipped trim retailed for $21,460. Because these enthusiast-oriented models are increasingly scarce, typical secondary market pricing around $20,000 reflects a remarkably low depreciation rate of just 6.8% over half a decade.

Toyota RAV4: 75.7%

Describing the Toyota RAV4 as simply popular understates its massive market footprint. In 2021 alone, Toyota delivered more than 400,000 examples of the crossover in the United States, securing its status as the best-selling non-truck vehicle of that model year. While this immense sales volume ensures a robust supply of used models, high supply has not translated into deep discounts for used-car shoppers.

Valuations provided by CarEdge at 76.5% and iSeeCars at 74.8% average out to a collective 75.7% retention rate. In practical terms, however, finding a well-maintained, five-year-old RAV4 that has actually depreciated by the forecasted 24.3% proves challenging, as real-world dealer pricing remains notably firm.

A base RAV4 LE equipped with front-wheel drive originally carried a sticker price of $27,045 in 2021. Five years later, active dealer listings average approximately $23,500, representing a strong residual value of 86.9%. Stepping up to the mid-tier XLE Premium trim reveals slightly higher nominal depreciation, with average dealer asking prices hovering near $26,300 against an original MSRP of $31,045, or roughly 84.7%. Market trackers note that secondary market pricing for pre-owned RAV4s has demonstrated continued resilience, even as broader automotive market indices fluctuate.

Toyota 4Runner: 75.4%

Among Toyota’s SUV lineup, the rugged 4Runner stands as the highest-ranking model for preserving its original MSRP over a five-year ownership cycle. CarEdge and iSeeCars report closely aligned resale projections of 76.3% and 74.5% respectively for the 2021 model year, averaging 75.4%.

This particular vintage represents the twilight of the vehicle’s long-running fifth generation, which remained a staple of the automaker’s portfolio from 2010 through 2024. Powered exclusively by a 4.0-liter V6 engine for the 2021 model year—prior to the introduction of turbocharged four-cylinder and hybrid options in the subsequent generation—the older architecture remains heavily sought after by buyers prioritizing mechanical simplicity and off-road capability.

An entry-level SR5 trim equipped with standard rear-wheel drive commands an average listing price of about $31,600 on the secondary market, compared to its original MSRP of $37,940. That math calculates to a remaining value of 83.3%, outperforming baseline forecasts by roughly 8 percentage points. Meanwhile, the mid-grade TRD Off-Road Premium, which originally opened at $44,225, routinely trades near $40,000 used. This represents a remarkably low depreciation rate of just 10.1% over a five-year period, leaving a residual value of 90.4%.

Toyota Corolla Sedan: 70.6%

Although the traditional four-door Corolla sedan does not match the staggering sales volume of the RAV4 crossover, Toyota nevertheless moved nearly 250,000 units of the compact sedan in the United States in 2021. Consequently, prospective buyers encounter little difficulty locating five-year-old examples across dealership lots nationwide.

Market analytics from CarEdge indicate that Corollas of this vintage retain 68.8% of their original value, while iSeeCars reports a slightly higher residual figure of 72.4%. However, much like the broader trend observed across Toyota’s portfolio, the combined 70.6% average fails to fully capture current real-world marketplace dynamics, where strong demand for affordable, fuel-efficient transportation keeps pre-owned values elevated.

The volume-selling LE trim for the 2021 Corolla debuted with an MSRP of $21,270, yet current secondary market listings average roughly $19,200. This performance translates to a 90.3% residual value, marking a notable variance from aggregated long-term forecasts. Interestingly, the sportier SE grade—which originally commanded a higher MSRP of $23,270 in 2021—now commands average market pricing around $19,100 on Autotrader, positioning it as a comparatively strong value for used-car buyers looking for higher-trim features without paying a steep premium.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *