Sugar substitutes have long been marketed and embraced as a healthier way to enjoy sweet foods and beverages without taking on the heavy calorie load and metabolic risks associated with regular sugar. From diet sodas and flavored waters to protein bars, energy drinks, and light yogurts, these ingredients are deeply embedded in the modern diet. However, newly published research suggests that some of these widely used low- and no-calorie sweeteners may carry an unexpected and concerning downside for long-term brain health.
A comprehensive study published in Neurology, the medical journal of the American Academy of Neurology, has found that adults who consumed the highest amounts of low- and no-calorie sweeteners experienced significantly faster declines in memory and overall thinking skills over time compared to those who consumed the least. This association was especially pronounced among individuals living with diabetes, a population that frequently relies on sugar substitutes to help manage blood sugar levels.
Researchers closely examined seven distinct sweeteners commonly found in commercial foods and beverages: aspartame, saccharin, acesulfame-K, erythritol, xylitol, sorbitol, and tagatose. These chemical compounds and sugar alcohols frequently appear in ultra-processed products sitting on grocery store shelves, and many of them are also sold individually in packets for consumers to stir into coffee, tea, and homemade recipes.
"Low- and no-calorie sweeteners are often seen as a healthy alternative to sugar; however, our findings suggest certain sweeteners may have negative effects on brain health over time," said lead study author Dr. Claudia Kimie Suemoto, MD, PhD, an investigator at the University of São Paulo in Brazil.
While the findings paint a sobering picture for habitual consumers of diet products, researchers emphasize that the study demonstrates an observational association rather than a proven cause-and-effect relationship. Consequently, scientists cannot conclude from this single investigation that consuming these sweeteners directly damages brain tissue or independently causes memory loss. Nevertheless, the strength of the statistical correlation has raised fresh questions within the medical community regarding the long-term systemic effects of chemical sugar substitutes.
Study Tracks Nearly 13,000 Adults for Eight Years
To investigate whether sugar substitutes might be connected to changes in cognitive health, researchers analyzed longitudinal data gathered from 12,772 adult participants across Brazil. The participants were, on average, 52 years old at the beginning of the study, placing them squarely in middle age—a critical window for observing early signs of cognitive aging before clinical symptoms of dementia or severe cognitive impairment typically manifest. The cohort was followed for approximately eight years, allowing researchers to track subtle shifts in mental acuity over a meaningful stretch of time.
At the launch of the investigation, participants completed detailed dietary questionnaires describing the foods and beverages they had consumed over the previous year. Research teams used these self-reported dietary responses to estimate each individual’s daily intake of the seven target sweeteners.
To make sense of the wide range of consumption levels, researchers divided the participants into three distinct groups based on how many milligrams of sweeteners they ingested each day. Participants assigned to the lowest consumption group averaged a modest 20 milligrams per day. By contrast, individuals in the highest consumption group averaged 191 milligrams per day. To put that upper figure into a practical perspective, 191 milligrams of aspartame is roughly equivalent to the amount found in a single standard can of diet soda.
Among all seven sweeteners analyzed by the research team, sorbitol registered the highest average daily intake, coming in at 64 milligrams per day. Sorbitol belongs to a specific category of sweeteners known as sugar alcohols, which naturally or synthetically provide sweet flavors and are heavily relied upon by food manufacturers seeking to reduce sugar content without sacrificing taste.
To evaluate changes in mental faculties, participants completed standardized cognitive assessments at three specific intervals: the beginning, the middle, and the end of the study period. These rigorous tests measured several core mental abilities essential for everyday functioning, including episodic memory, linguistic capabilities, and the speed at which the brain processes complex information.
Specifically, researchers evaluated verbal fluency—the cognitive ability to quickly retrieve and produce words under specific constraints—alongside working memory, which allows people to temporarily hold, manipulate, and utilize information in real-time. They also tested word recall and general processing speed to determine how these vital cognitive functions shifted as the participants grew older during the eight-year tracking period.
High Sweetener Consumption Linked to 62% Faster Cognitive Decline
When the data was fully compiled and analyzed, the results revealed a striking and quantifiable difference in cognitive trajectories between the people who consumed the most sweeteners and those who consumed the least.
After carefully accounting for a wide array of confounding health and demographic factors that could influence cognitive health—including age, sex, high blood pressure, and pre-existing cardiovascular disease—the researchers discovered that participants in the highest consumption group experienced a 62% faster decline in overall thinking and memory abilities compared with those in the lowest consumption group.
To help contextualize these statistical findings for the public, researchers calculated that this accelerated rate of decline was equivalent to approximately 1.6 additional years of cognitive aging accumulated over the course of the study period.
Even moderate consumption was associated with measurable differences in brain performance. Participants in the middle consumption tier experienced a 35% faster decline in cognitive function than those consuming the least, an effect equivalent to roughly 1.3 additional years of accelerated cognitive aging.
It is important to note that these estimates describe measured changes in cognitive test performance over time rather than a direct, physical measurement of biological brain aging or cellular degradation. Furthermore, the researchers stressed that these statistical associations do not imply that every single person who consumes artificial or low-calorie sweeteners will inevitably develop memory problems or cognitive decline.
Stronger Links Found in Adults Under 60 and People With Diabetes
When the research team broke down the data across different demographic and health categories, they discovered that the association between sweeteners and cognitive decline was not distributed evenly across all participants.
Among adults younger than 60 years old, higher sweetener consumption was robustly linked to faster declines in verbal fluency and overall cognitive performance. Interestingly, researchers did not find a similar statistical association among participants older than 60, suggesting that middle-aged brains may be particularly vulnerable to whatever mechanisms underlie this relationship.
Furthermore, the relationship between sweetener intake and cognitive decline was notably stronger in people with diabetes compared to those without the condition. This finding carries significant public health implications, as people with diabetes frequently rely heavily on artificial sweeteners and sugar substitutes as a primary strategy to manage their carbohydrate and blood sugar intake.
Examining the seven sweeteners individually revealed another important distinction. Six of the seven substances evaluated were independently associated with faster declines in overall cognitive performance, with memory taking the most pronounced hit.
Those six widely used substances were aspartame, saccharin, acesulfame-K, erythritol, sorbitol, and xylitol.
Tagatose stood out as the sole exception in the group. Researchers found no statistically significant association between tagatose consumption and cognitive decline in this study. However, the study authors cautioned that this absence of evidence does not establish that tagatose actively protects the brain or is inherently safer for long-term consumption than its chemical counterparts.
Should People Rethink Artificial Sweeteners?
The publication of these findings raises complex questions for both consumers and healthcare providers about whether substituting refined sugar with low-calorie alternatives always delivers the health benefits people expect, particularly when it comes to the long-term well-being of the brain.
"While we found links to cognitive decline for middle-aged people both with and without diabetes, people with diabetes are more likely to use artificial sweeteners as sugar substitutes," Dr. Suemoto noted. She added that additional scientific investigation is urgently needed to confirm these findings and to explore whether other refined sugar alternatives—such as natural options like applesauce, honey, maple syrup, or coconut sugar—might serve as safer or more effective alternatives in the human diet.
The study’s authors also acknowledged several inherent limitations in their methodology. For one, the analysis did not cover every single artificial or low-calorie sweetener currently available on the commercial market, meaning the findings cannot necessarily be generalized to all sugar substitutes in existence.
Additionally, the dietary information relied heavily on participants’ retrospective recollections of what they had eaten and drunk over the previous year. Because human memory is imperfect, and because individuals frequently forget specific food items, underestimate portion sizes, or inaccurately report their daily dietary habits, these estimates may not perfectly reflect absolute, real-world sweetener consumption.
Furthermore, because the research relied on an observational design, the possibility remains that other unmeasured lifestyle or dietary factors could help explain the observed statistical relationship between sweetener intake and cognitive decline, despite the research team’s rigorous efforts to control for major health variables.
Moving forward, further clinical and epidemiological studies will be required to determine whether these specific sweeteners directly contribute to biochemical changes in human brain function, why certain demographic groups appear more strongly affected than others, and what long-term cognitive outcomes are associated with different classes of sugar alternatives.
The research project received financial support and backing from the Brazilian Ministry of Health, the Ministry of Science, Technology, and Innovation, and the National Council for Scientific and Technological Development.