By her own admission, Marjorie Steele does not get along with many people in the contemporary climate movement. Operating out of Michigan, she runs a grassroots activist organization that advocates heavily against large-scale industrial development across the state. Although she considers herself a political independent, her fierce opposition to incoming corporate projects frequently places her at odds with both mainstream climate advocates and Trump-aligned conservatives.

While she spends the majority of her time these days focusing on the rapid proliferation of energy-hungry data centers, Steele initially founded her activist organization—the Economic Development Responsibility Alliance—to oppose a controversial Chinese electric vehicle battery plant slated near the city of Big Rapids. Beyond that primary battleground, she has aggressively campaigned against an array of infrastructure projects, including sprawling solar farms, massive battery storage systems, and high-voltage transmission lines, one of which is currently being constructed directly on the property adjacent to her own land.

“When the progressives look at me and say, ‘You’re MAGA’ because of the green energy issue, it really hurts me,” Steele said. As she has traversed the state crossing paths with various new development projects, she has routinely encountered fierce, sometimes hostile pushback from climate-conscious progressives who view any opposition to renewable energy as a betrayal of environmental goals.

Yet, amidst this tense political landscape, there has been one notable exception. Earlier this year, while visiting the state capital of Lansing to lobby state lawmakers for a sweeping moratorium on data center construction, Steele crossed paths with William Lawrence, a progressive Democrat running for the U.S. House of Representatives in Michigan’s highly competitive 7th Congressional District. Knowing that Lawrence was a prominent co-founder of the Sunrise Movement—one of the nation’s most influential youth-led climate organizations—Steele was initially uncertain how the candidate would receive her critiques.

The two sat down to share a casual lunch of Jimmy John’s sandwiches, and Steele proceeded to speak to him at length about what she views as the profoundly negative consequences of clean energy development, pointing specifically to relentless construction noise, environmental disruption, and the rapid destruction of prime agricultural farmland.

“I let him have it,” she recalled of the encounter. “I just gave him the whole spiel rather forcefully. And he listened and he asked amazing questions. He’s clearly actual grassroots, otherwise he wouldn’t be at my table, because mainstream establishment politicians do not like talking to me.”

A few weeks after that meeting, Steele watched Lawrence participate in a media interview where he appeared to echo many of the core points she had laid out during their lunch. Consequently, the Economic Development Responsibility Alliance took the unusual step of endorsing his congressional campaign—a rare move for an organization that typically avoids backing major-party candidates.

Across the Lansing metropolitan area and throughout many other parts of the country, communities have experienced a sudden, fierce public uproar against an unprecedented data center boom. Multiple massive hyperscale projects have suddenly cropped up in communities across the state, including a staggering $16 billion Oracle-OpenAI campus currently under construction near Ann Arbor. Driven by these rapid developments, more than a dozen local municipal governments have actively attempted to enact local bans or stringent zoning restrictions.

In Lansing proper, intense local backlash successfully tanked a smaller proposal known as the Deep Green data center earlier this year. This occurred despite the developer’s ambitious public promises to recycle industrial waste heat and utilize minimal water resources.

The Michigan climate candidate courting opponents of Big Solar

The fears voiced by local activists run the gamut from heavy water and power consumption to severe noise and artificial light pollution. Significantly, this rising coalition appears to comfortably span traditional partisan lines, uniting eclectic factions from MAGA conservatives to left-leaning progressives. It also heavily incorporates rural residents and independent landowners, like Steele, who find themselves united by a shared refusal to see industrial renewables or digital infrastructure built in their backyards.

The high-stakes congressional race in the Lansing area now represents a critical test of whether major-party political candidates can successfully channel these simmering, cross-partisan anti-development sentiments into a viable path toward electoral victory. Lawrence emerged directly from the mainstream climate movement and, like many orthodox Democrats, recognizes the party’s desire to see new restrictions placed on data center development. However, running a competitive campaign in Lansing has also required him to forge common cause with skeptical rural voters who harbor deep reservations about solar panels and large-scale clean energy installations.

As Lawrence sees it, the political and environmental stakes of this balancing act are extraordinarily high. The ultimate success or failure of his coalition-building effort could very well determine not only the narrow partisan control of the U.S. House of Representatives, but also the long-term viability of the country’s broader transition away from fossil fuels.

“I think it’s all up in the air right now,” Lawrence remarked regarding the mood of the electorate. “It’s really hard to tell which way it will lean… It is genuinely cross-partisan. People do not believe that anybody at the top of business and government is looking out for them.”

The 7th Congressional District, which encompasses the city of Lansing alongside a wide swath of surrounding suburbs and rural townships, stands firmly as one of the few true toss-up swing districts in the country. Moderate Democrat Elissa Slotkin successfully held the seat three times by remarkably slim margins. However, when Slotkin vacated the district to launch a successful run for the U.S. Senate in 2024, Republican challenger Tom Barrett won the seat back by a narrow margin. Barrett is now running for reelection, setting up a marquee battleground matchup.

On paper, the 36-year-old Lawrence might seem like an ill-fitting candidate for such a traditionally purple district. Tall and lanky, with a cerebral and deliberate speaking style, he projects the distinct aura of an academic graduate student far more than that of a traditional Midwestern farmer or auto assembly worker. In 2015, Lawrence co-founded the Sunrise Movement driven by the foundational theory that solving the global climate crisis required disruptive, confrontational activism and sweeping, top-down government intervention.

In November 2018, Lawrence and his fellow co-founders famously organized a high-profile sit-in directly inside then-House Democratic Leader Nancy Pelosi’s congressional office, forcefully demanding the adoption of a Green New Deal that would mandate massive federal public investments in clean energy infrastructure. At one point, he was even a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, though he now states that he no longer identifies as a socialist. Furthermore, in a series of since-deleted social media posts from 2020, he voiced support for policies such as "free and open migration" and the abolition of traditional policing.

Despite this undeniably progressive ideological background, Lawrence managed to secure 40 percent of the vote in a crowded Democratic primary in August, successfully defeating two centrist opponents who ultimately split the moderate wing of the electorate between them. Since clinching the nomination, he has earned the official endorsement of the Democratic Party’s national congressional leadership, even though party brass had initially attempted to block his rise during the primary contest. Furthermore, he has kept robust financial pace with Barrett in what has rapidly transformed into one of the most expensive House races in the nation, with Barrett drawing substantial financial backing from major Republican political action committees as well as the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.

Lawrence has managed this competitive footing in large part by campaigning with the rigorous discipline of a seasoned community organizer. His campaign operation has successfully knocked on more than 100,000 doors across the district, while Lawrence himself has hosted dozens of unscripted town hall meetings designed to take unfiltered, direct questions from local constituents. Moreover, he has actively integrated his campaign into local policy fights, most notably around the explosive issue of data centers. Last month, he made a targeted appearance at a city council meeting in the town of Mason to voice vocal opposition to a potential data center proposal, standing shoulder-to-shoulder with local residents who arrived at the chamber wearing crimson-red baseball caps.

However, the deep-seated anti-development opposition taking root in communities like Lansing extends far beyond data centers alone. It routinely encompasses solar farms, commercial battery storage systems, and massive high-voltage transmission lines designed to carry renewable electricity directly to major metropolitan centers. While these specific technologies are widely recognized by energy experts as some of the cheapest and most efficient tools available for replacing fossil-fuel-fired power plants on the electrical grid, they also require vast tracts of land, making them an inevitable target for intense local pushback.

The Michigan climate candidate courting opponents of Big Solar

“We’ve definitely seen some bleed over from data center opposition to all types of infrastructure development,” observed Ed Rivet, executive director of the Michigan Conservative Energy Forum, a right-leaning organization that advocates for clean energy expansion. Rivet noted that this growing wave of “infrastructure fatigue” is deeply “unfortunate… because these other types of projects will have tangible benefits for customers in terms of cost, reliability, and cleaner energy.”

The deployment of commercial solar infrastructure has become a particular flashpoint of controversy in Michigan, where state policy aims to transition the power grid entirely to clean energy sources by the year 2040. After numerous local municipal governments enacted restrictive zoning ordinances explicitly designed to ban new solar installations, the Michigan state legislature passed a contentious law in 2023 that preempted those local statutes. Under the current legal framework, renewable energy developers can now bypass resistant local boards and apply directly to the state government for construction approval if they fail to secure local permits.

The very first utility-scale project permitted under this state override law, known as Assembly Solar, recently finished construction on the eastern edge of Lawrence’s congressional district, sparking widespread outrage among area residents. Lawrence told reporters that a local homeowner recently took him on a personal tour of the completed solar facility to demonstrate firsthand how the massive array has permanently disrupted the region’s traditional agrarian lifestyle. With additional utility projects already moving forward under the state siting authority, Lawrence has repeatedly criticized the preemption policy in various public forums. In a recent radio appearance, he argued that wind and solar critics have “some good points” and contended that the state solar preemption has effectively allowed powerful utility companies to “build mega projects without community buy-in.”

Lawrence explains his underlying skepticism toward large-scale clean energy development by arguing that the traditional process of economic development in the United States is fundamentally broken. In his view, ordinary communities are given virtually no meaningful voice over whether a massive data center or an industrial solar farm is placed in their backyards, and they are given little reason to trust that these projects offer genuine local benefits. While large infrastructure projects occasionally generate temporary construction jobs and modest tax revenues for local municipal governments, they produce very few permanent, long-term careers, and the vast majority of financial profits flow entirely out of the region. Meanwhile, local residents are left to contend permanently with heavy construction noise and major aesthetic disruptions.

“What’s clear is that people just don’t believe that investments that are directed from outside of the district, from somewhere else in the state or somewhere else in the country or the world, are going to benefit them,” Lawrence said. He added that he has heard “a lot of concerns” regarding the state solar law specifically, and emphasized that those local grievances must be taken “very seriously.”

While Lawrence acknowledges that it remains an open question what an alternative model of industrial development might look like, he is eager to explore new frameworks. “It’s an open question,” he stated, “and I’ll leave it at that.”

As potential solutions, Lawrence advocates for the establishment of a public bank capable of financing public infrastructure without demanding exorbitant profit margins. He also suggests leveraging the traditional "convening power" of a congressional office to bring private developers and community members together for transparent discussions regarding “what we want to build, why, and how.” He suggests that developers might successfully defuse local opposition by voluntarily sharing corporate revenues directly with the host communities where they build data centers or solar arrays, or by making binding commitments to local conservation and water resource protection. In the interim, however, he continues to call for a nationwide moratorium on new data center construction.

Lawrence freely concedes that his past activist efforts with the Sunrise Movement stand in sharp philosophical tension with his current political focus on hyper-local community control over economic development. The Sunrise Movement’s hallmark legislative proposal was the Green New Deal, which aggressively argued that the federal government should orchestrate the construction of massive amounts of new energy infrastructure while simultaneously seizing regulatory control over entire sectors like housing and healthcare. The inherent implication of such sweeping federal programs is that centralized government bodies, rather than individual neighborhoods or municipalities, ultimately decide what infrastructure gets built and where it goes. Having departed the organization in 2020 to spend years working as a grassroots tenant organizer in his home state of Michigan, Lawrence says he now views the entire climate crisis through a radically different lens.

“I think in that era, you know, we were thinking about the necessity of the outcome, and now I’m thinking more about what is necessary in the process,” Lawrence explained. “And I’m reckoning with just how little trust we all have.”

Anti-development activists in Michigan, such as Marjorie Steele, are quick to clarify that they are not inherently opposed to solar technology as a concept, but rather object to massive industrial projects that permanently erase productive farmland and generate corporate windfalls primarily for major utilities. Steele’s organization actively supports smaller-scale "community solar" installations designed to supply electricity specifically to localized populations, as well as emerging agrivoltaic initiatives that allow for the continued agricultural farming of crops directly underneath elevated solar panels.

The Michigan climate candidate courting opponents of Big Solar

“I don’t want to make it seem like green energy is a big boogeyman,” Steele noted. “We’re solutions-oriented.” Her alliance has conceptualized a vision for an “agricultural renaissance community” featuring thriving small businesses, protected farmland, open park spaces, and light manufacturing, potentially powered entirely by local community solar grids.

However, energy experts caution that these decentralized proposals face severe structural limitations. Doug Bessette, a professor who studies energy development at Michigan State University and has collaborated with various groups advocating for community solar and agrivoltaics, points out that smaller installations cannot generate power at the massive scale required to replace coal and natural gas-fired power plants. To put the scale in perspective, Michigan currently utilizes approximately 14,000 megawatts of natural gas generation capacity, whereas a typical community solar project generates a capacity of only between 1 and 5 megawatts.

“In order to fully transition our economy to clean energy, you have to build huge solar and huge wind and huge batteries and you have to do it fast,” Bessette said. “The smaller-is-better approach honestly would be ineffective at actually mitigating emissions at the rate at which we need to do it—and would also be more expensive.”

If Michigan and other states fail to find a viable mechanism to appease vocal critics of large-scale solar projects, each incoming installation risks generating compounding public backlash, making future infrastructure projects exponentially harder to construct. Already, hundreds of rural counties across the broader Midwest have attempted to restrict or outright ban commercial solar and wind construction, while organized activist groups along the Eastern Seaboard have mobilized heavily against offshore wind farm proposals. Notably, Lawrence is far more willing to acknowledge and engage with this deep-seated political friction than many traditional climate activists, who frequently dismiss all anti-renewable opposition as mere astroturfing orchestrated by conservative political groups.

Even so, not everyone is entirely convinced that Lawrence’s vision of a broad, cross-partisan political coalition is achievable in practice. Republican incumbent Tom Barrett has similarly worked to cast himself as a vocal skeptic of data center expansion. Jean Hardy, a professor at Michigan State University who has closely studied local government decision-making surrounding data center developments, expresses skepticism that Lawrence’s populist stance on the issue will successfully induce large numbers of conservative Republicans to cross party lines.

“Data center opposition is so bipartisan at this point that I don’t think it’s an issue that is going to activate people to switch sides or is going to organize independents in a particular way,” Hardy observed.

Despite these political doubts, Lawrence remains firmly convinced that Democratic politicians must actively acknowledge and channel this widespread public opposition, arguing that the imperative extends far beyond winning a single election in Lansing. From his perspective, reforming the prevailing American model of economic development is a mandatory, foundational step toward achieving a successful transition to clean energy. Until ordinary voters genuinely believe that energy infrastructure directly benefits their communities and that they retain a meaningful voice in shaping their local environments, any top-down attempts to construct clean power at scale are bound to encounter fierce resistance.

“The question is who can effectively connect the big ‘no’ that we’re all saying to data centers into an affirmative ‘yes’ about what we want to build,” Lawrence said.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *