The transition from pre-K to formal kindergarten can be an overwhelming milestone for many young children, marked by longer school days, increasingly structured learning environments, and much trickier social dynamics. While much of the national conversation surrounding early childhood education has focused heavily on expanding access to preschool and elevating overall program quality, experts argue that a vital piece of the puzzle is still missing. According to recent research and early childhood advocates, the key to a genuinely smooth and successful entry into elementary school lies in much stronger collaboration and coordination among elementary schools, early learning providers, healthcare systems, social service agencies, and families.
A striking illustration of these early hurdles comes from a study conducted by researchers at Ohio State University. In the study, kindergarten teachers reported that more than 70 percent of their incoming students experienced transition challenges in at least one major area—ranging from making friends and following complex daily schedules to meeting academic demands, working productively within groups, or staying organized. Even more alarming, over 30 percent of the surveyed teachers noted that their students struggled significantly across all five of those areas simultaneously.
David Jacobson, an early childhood education researcher and the director of the Education Development Center’s First 10 initiative—a nationwide program that actively engages elementary schools, school districts, early childhood programs, and community organizations to better support young children and their families—believes that traditional investments alone are not enough. While funding more preschool seats and improving curriculum quality are undoubtedly necessary steps, Jacobson points out that systemic gaps continue to leave children vulnerable as they cross the threshold from early learning environments into K-12 education.
In a recent discussion, Jacobson explored the current landscape of the pre-K to kindergarten transition, the root causes of systemic fragmentation, and how a more connected, community-wide approach can help young children successfully navigate this major educational shift.
The Landscape of Disconnection
Across the vast majority of communities in the United States, significant structural gaps and disconnects persist between early childhood systems—such as Head Start, state-funded pre-K, and community-based preschools—and the formal K-12 education sector. Frequently, these chasms exist even between a district’s own pre-K classrooms and its K-5 or K-6 elementary school buildings. In cases where preschool programs are located off-site, pre-K educators are often surprisingly isolated from the broader elementary school community.
Furthermore, many preschools and K-12 schools operate with limited connections to essential health and social services. Consequently, these vital programs often function in total isolation, leaving families to navigate a confusing maze of community services. In many instances, valuable resources exist within a community, but families simply remain unaware of them or do not know how to access them effectively.
For young children, these structural gaps translate into abrupt transitions and a fundamental lack of alignment. Their daily learning experiences are rarely connected, reinforced, or built upon from one setting to the next. Behind the scenes, the educators themselves often remain strangers to one another. Elementary school principals frequently do not know the directors of their feeder preschools by name, let alone maintain collaborative professional relationships with them. Similarly, pre-K and kindergarten teachers often work in silos, despite the reality that the children sitting in preschool classrooms will soon populate kindergarten desks.
While kindergarten teachers stand to benefit immensely from understanding what children experienced in pre-K, and pre-K teachers need insight into kindergarten expectations to properly prepare their students, this level of communication is rarely the status quo. Educators generally lack the formal opportunities and institutional structures required to foster these vital connections.
The Value of Alignment and Community Cohesion
When children experience environments that are safe, stable, and deeply connected across the day, across various settings, and across consecutive years, they reap profound developmental benefits. What a child experiences during the morning hours should seamlessly connect with what happens in an after-school program. Learning in kindergarten must purposefully build upon what was mastered in pre-K, while preschool programs should prepare children for kindergarten in a manner that remains developmentally appropriate.
When these experiences are properly aligned, children naturally feel more secure, learning is consistently reinforced, and families encounter a public education system that actually makes sense. From a district perspective, acknowledging this continuity means recognizing that a child’s formal learning journey does not simply begin on the very first day of kindergarten.
Moreover, communities serve as critical units of social and developmental change. Broader community conditions shape children’s developmental outcomes independently of the individual socioeconomic circumstances of their families. Extensive research demonstrates that communities characterized by high levels of social trust, mutual cohesion, and strong inter-organizational connections consistently perform better across a wide variety of outcomes, including child health, safety, and long-term civic engagement. Taken together, these principles build a compelling case for coordinated action across schools, early childhood programs, health agencies, social services, local libraries, and families, replacing the fragmented status quo with a unified support network.
Overcoming Historical and Structural Divides
The persistence of the current fragmented system stems largely from long-standing cultural distinctions between education and care. Society has historically viewed young children as needing basic care rather than true education, while simultaneously treating K-12 schools as centers of education devoid of caregiving responsibilities. In reality, human beings require a continuous integration of learning and nurturing from before birth throughout their entire lives. This artificial divide between early childhood programs and K-12 schooling is deeply rooted in cultural understandings and further perpetuated by complex funding streams.

The United States operates deeply fragmented local early childhood systems, often referred to as mixed-delivery systems. These systems encompass a wide array of independent providers and distinct funding streams that are rarely coordinated. Head Start relies on federal funding, state-funded pre-K operates under separate guidelines, and low-income families might utilize child care vouchers for community-based programs, while school districts may run their own localized pre-K offerings. Combining these intricate structural funding factors with traditional cultural perceptions creates massive systemic gaps.
Compounding this issue is the tendency of school districts over the past several decades to think exclusively about educational improvement in a vertical direction. When students struggle academically in the ninth grade, educational leaders typically examine ninth-grade structures and supports while also looking backward to middle school. Similarly, middle school challenges prompt examinations of both the transition into middle school and the conclusion of elementary school.
This vertical cascade generally extends from local businesses looking toward community colleges, which look to high schools, which look to middle schools, and finally to elementary schools—at which point the upward look largely stops. This phenomenon represents a final vertical leap. While districts attempt to align higher levels of education theoretically, bridging the gap into early childhood remains a distinct operational challenge because pre-K programs typically operate outside the official district hierarchy, leaving school leaders with limited knowledge of their curricula, practices, or staff.
To bridge this divide, communities across the country have begun turning to structural solutions known as early childhood hubs and zones, which help districts successfully make that final vertical leap into early learning.
Hubs and Zones in Action
An early childhood zone brings together multiple elementary schools, the various early childhood programs that feed students into them, and relevant community providers—such as public health and social service agencies—within a clearly defined geographical area, such as a small school district or a specific neighborhood within a larger city.
A hub organizes similar collaborative work around a single elementary school and its immediate network of nearby early childhood and community partners. This model effectively extends the proven framework of a full-service community school downward to embrace younger children and their families before they officially enter the K-12 system.
Several states and local communities have already implemented hubs and zones with remarkable success. Alabama, for instance, has established 14 early childhood hubs across the state, operating in diverse rural settings as well as urban centers like Montgomery and Mobile, alongside several suburban communities.
Similarly, Maine’s Department of Education has championed six regional hubs to support its extensive rural communities. In Sanford, Maine, where more than 50 percent of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, local leaders have embraced the hub model to build powerful cross-sector connections.
In Pennsylvania, Conestoga Valley within Lancaster County represents a unique community featuring a rural landscape on one end, an urban center on the other, more than 50 spoken languages, and some of the highest rates of economic need in the county. Meanwhile, the urban center of York, Pennsylvania, where 90 to 95 percent of students receive free or reduced-price meals, has taken the unusual step of embracing both citywide zones and individual hubs simultaneously. York utilized its zone framework to launch a comprehensive early math initiative, bringing together Head Start teachers, community-based pre-K instructors, district pre-K staff, kindergarten teachers, and even first- and second-grade educators to implement a unified set of early math games both in classrooms and at home.
Building Toward Collaboration
For school administrators and early childhood program leaders seeking to initiate similar collaborative efforts, experts emphasize that the foundational step requires securing initial leadership buy-in from both the school district and at least a few key early childhood providers. From there, leaders must conduct an honest asset and needs assessment to evaluate current practices, existing levels of collaboration, available community resources, and the strength of current ties between elementary schools and preschool programs.
Rather than getting bogged down in endless planning cycles, advocates suggest beginning with manageable starter practices to spark momentum, noting that early collaboration naturally generates opportunities for deeper cooperation. This behind-the-scenes alignment requires educators to examine educational standards, review shared curricula, analyze instructional challenges, and exchange best practices together.
Just as a single academic year separates kindergarten from first grade, the same span separates pre-K from kindergarten, making teacher collaboration across that boundary just as critical. When educators cross these traditional institutional divides to work together, they frequently find the experience profoundly inspiring, motivating, and practically valuable, opening the door for libraries and other community organizations to join the collaborative mission.