There is a fabulous Italian expression: boh.

It is one of those words you feel when you say it. It starts deep in your belly and expands upward. Your lips purse for the "buh," then open into the "ohhhh," which you can stretch as long as needed. And its meaning? Well, that is harder to explain.

Boh suggests not knowing. But it can communicate resignation, skepticism, indifference, or bemusement. It means all these things and none of them exactly; it does not really translate. In the film Spider-Man: Far From Home, the character MJ discovers boh on a school trip to Italy and becomes entirely enchanted by it.

I became enchanted with boh, too, years ago as a young teacher working at an international school situated in a small Italian city. The vast majority of my preschool students were local Italian children whose parents were eager to have them immersed in English. As a result, I was expected to speak strictly in English with them throughout the school day.

One morning, after meticulously setting up playful activities with great intention around my classroom, two students arrived together. Eagerly, I showed them some materials I was certain they would love and asked if they wanted to try them out.

One boy looked at me with raised eyebrows, side-eyed his friend, shrugged deeply, and said, "Bohhhh." Then, they immediately walked away to play with the train set instead.

At the time, I strictly followed the school’s English-only expectations. But the longer I spent in the classroom, the less comfortable I became with a pedagogical philosophy that effectively asked children to leave their home language outside the door. Eventually, that growing discomfort contributed significantly to my decision to leave the institution.

Multilingual children possess an extraordinary capacity to teach us about how we communicate and to open our eyes to a more interesting, diverse world. As educators, we fundamentally miss out on that profound learning when we do not allow children to show up in our classrooms with every single part of who they are—including their home languages.

What’s Ahead for Head Start

Children and teachers alike stand to lose under a proposed Trump administration rule that would require Head Start programs to conduct all instruction entirely in English. If enacted, this policy would undo established 2016 standards that actively support bilingualism and would divert critical federal funds away from multilingual services toward English-language-only education and a broader framework of assimilation.

In my professional experience, English-only policies send a remarkably powerful and damaging message to young children: The language you bring from home—that of your parents and grandparents, the language of jokes, comforting songs, and bedtime stories—does not belong in school. Such policies also rob educators of rich, irreplaceable opportunities for genuine connection and shared learning.

I now work in a U.S. preschool featuring publicly funded pre-K classrooms, housed within a historic church that boasts a magnificent golden cockerel, which our students fondly call a "rooster," perched atop its steeple. In 2023, that striking bird statue was taken down by crane for preservation work, a dramatic spectacle that completely captivated our preschool community.

I vividly remember talking about the event with a bilingual student, and our conversation naturally turned to the specific sounds roosters make. This child was keen to teach me what a rooster "says" in Portuguese, the language her family speaks at home. I offered what it says in Italian, the language my family uses at home. Then we arrived at English, the language we shared at school, and we laughed together at that funny-sounding version.

It was a tiny, fleeting interaction—nothing that would ever appear on a formal developmental assessment or a kindergarten-readiness checklist. But we were bonding. She was showing me something she knew that I did not. Together, we appreciated the absurdity that even roosters become "multilingual" depending entirely on who is listening.

If our program treated children’s home languages as something to be left at the classroom threshold, we might have missed that entire moment: the chuckle, the inside joke, and the invaluable opportunity for a young child to be the expert while her teacher stepped into the role of the learner.

A Missed Opportunity

Approximately one-third of children under the age of five in the United States are dual language learners, according to a 2025 report published by the National Center on Immigrant Integration Policy, which is part of the Migration Policy Institute. Within federal Head Start programs, these children bring more than 140 distinct languages into their classrooms. While we cannot reasonably expect every early childhood educator to fluently speak the home language of every child, we can certainly build classrooms that treat those languages as legitimate and valuable assets.

Head Start’s current standards directly reflect this supportive philosophy. They explicitly recognize "bilingualism and biliteracy as strengths" and call for instructional practices that support children’s acquisition of English while simultaneously nurturing and supporting their home languages.

A growing body of academic research firmly backs this approach. For instance, a 2018 Elsevier study examining nearly 2,000 dual language learners enrolled in Head Start programs found that utilizing Spanish alongside English did not impede the children’s English language development in any way.

However, focusing exclusively on measurable academic outcomes like these misses something vital.

It misses boh. It misses the multilingual animals. It misses the jokes, gestures, and cultural expressions that do not quite translate into standard metrics. It misses the pure delight of a child realizing she knows something her teacher does not. And it overlooks something fundamental to the healthy development of young children: human relationships.

Yet these are precisely the kinds of intangible, meaningful experiences that could become much harder to nurture if the proposed changes to Head Start standards become law. It remains unclear how such a rigid requirement would ultimately translate into everyday classroom interactions, but I cannot help wondering whether teachers would begin to hesitate before inviting a child to share a word in their home language, or whether spontaneous moments of connection like the ones I have cherished would become increasingly difficult to accommodate.

In the process, educators would lose something profound as well. We would miss crucial opportunities to become better observers, better communicators, and more empathetic practitioners. We would miss the wonderful pedagogical reversal that happens when a three-year-old child suddenly becomes the expert and the grown-up gets to be the student.

That morning as a young teacher in Italy, the children taught me that my well-intended invitation relied far too heavily on spoken language alone. I needed a much deeper toolkit for teaching young children whose home language differed from my own. They taught me how language carries meaning not only through explicit words, but also through gesture, expression, sound, culture, and shared understanding. That day, they made me a substantially better teacher.

The school where I currently work is not a Head Start program, meaning these proposed federal changes would not directly govern our classrooms. Even so, I do not believe that lets me off the hook. Those of us working in other early childhood settings have a vital role to play in supporting our Head Start colleagues.

We can continue making room for all of children’s languages in our classrooms, and we can share the valuable lessons learned from those experiences with families, colleagues, community organizations, and policymakers alike. Stories like these help bring the everyday realities of teaching and learning into critical policy conversations. The formal public comment period for the proposed Head Start rule closed on October 6, and educators nationwide now await a final decision. But whatever the ultimate outcome of the proposal may be, these conversations must not end.

Why would anyone design public policies that leave out so much human value? I have only one answer—and it does not quite translate.

Boh.